|  |
| Customer Reviews: | | Average Customer Review: ( 74 customer reviews )
Write an online review and share your thoughts with other customers.
Most Helpful Customer Reviews
121 of 125 found the following review helpful:
 Almost Perfect! Aug 11, 2009
By N. Nguyen
The drill is powerful and the hammer action is good for cement and brick fastner drilling. My only gripe is the chuck doesn't bite as hard as my Dewalt. The impact fastner is a beast! Light compact and battery last a really long time. I'm a general contractor and have Dewalt and Milwaukee lithium tools to compare. Makita and Dewalt win this round of lithium tools. Tool quality is excellent. The LED light and belt clip are handy.
This tool has gotten fantastic reviews. Ignore the few bad ones. This tool is heavy duty and can handle my punishment as a contractor. We use it every day. It is not made for computer nerds that can build computers yet complain about the reverse switch.
It's amazing how ignorant some customers can be.
"The tool is too powerful and strips screws".....really?? It is a heavy duty tool with over 1330 in.lbs of torque.
"It is less powerful than my Milwaukee 28Volt".......really? Wanna compare apples to oranges?
"It takes two hands to change the hammer to drill action"......again really??? What is your other hand doing and how hard, how often do you change from hammer to drill??
41 of 42 found the following review helpful:
Spend the extra money for the LXT kit, the 3.0ah batteries are worth it. May 31, 2011
By Psyclaws
"Byron"
Don't buy the other little compact combo kit (LCT200W) unless you rarely plan to use these tools for more than a few hours at a time and really need to save on weight. Spend a few dollars more, double your battery life, and have the option to add more tools later. Right now, the compact 1.5ah batteries that come with the other kit (LCT200W) only operate three Makita tools (drill, driver, and a light). THIS LXT line with the 3.0 batteries operate 35 tools!
In regards to this kit (LXT211), ergo's are important, but most of us are more concerned with torque and battery life. The driver in this combo kit runs at 450 in.lbs, and the impacter hits at 1330 or so. Plenty of torque for whatever you can throw at these tools, and right there with the competition. The impact driver laughs at 3 and 3.5 inch screws! If you need more torque, you should be using a corded rotary hammer drill or ½" pnuematic impact wrench anyway. For my first use of these tools, we built a large 50'X50' deck around a 35' above-ground pool. We tied the 4X4 piers to the 2X8 deck framing with 5/16th lag bolts. I used the drill to bore seventy-five, 5" and 6.5" deep holes through wet, treated pine with an auger bit, and then bolted the nuts with the impact driver. All done on a single charge. I used a Senco Duraspin collated screw fastening system to drive the 2.5" deck screws (3000 of them), but kept my impact driver on my belt for misfeeds and tight spots. It ran all day. I charged it around lunch the first day just to keep it running efficiently, but the charger took less than ten minutes to top it off. The next two days of decking were done on a single charge. I then used the impact driver to set 3" screws for the handrails and stairs. A single lunch-time charge (or battery swap if I wasn't using the drill) kept me going. These Lith-Ion batteries are brutes! The ergos on both tools are terrific, and the weight to power ratio is phenomenal. I will agree that the forward / reverse switch can be inadvertently bumped while in the reverse position. However, it only happened to me when I was in a very awkward angle. For instance, when I was driving the fulcrum screw on a lever board used to suck in a warped deck board. Drilling below plane forces your hand to grip higher on the tool, and can lead to bumping the switch out of the reverse gear. Not really a big deal though, I only mentioned it because others have made a fuss about it. O yea, and fan noise on the charger, really??? It's no louder than a regular PC fan! Lightweight, powerful, and with lithium legs to keep it running all day! Highly recommended!
27 of 29 found the following review helpful:
Indispensable Workhorse Oct 15, 2009
By J. Martinez
Well built all around! Solid feel yet lightweight for an 18V system. Silently delivers torque and speed. The grip and rubberized body ergonomics are just about perfect. These Li-Ion batteries last FOREVER!!! And having a backup driver is almost SINFUL. This combo replaces a 15yr old Makita Ni-Cad system...only because of battery obolesence. Makita has never disappointed and continues to deliver.
Be advised the charger is a GIGUNDOUS beast (apparently there's a memory chip in the batts that the charger uses to determine optimal usage and charge rates...sucker even has a cooling fan). Consequently the hard case is a bit oversized...but do not let this deter from the performance.
The LED lights are icing on the cake. Even the belt clips have come in handy...who knew?
For those that do their homework - Check the specs and you'll see this unit is superior to the competition.
Nothing but love for Makita!
13 of 13 found the following review helpful:
What I'd expect from Makita May 13, 2011
By Kimberly Lazarski
"Kimberly"
I bought this set to replace two old 3/8' 9.6V Makita drills and I have to say I am impressed. My old 9.6V drill (model 6095D) has been going strong for almost 20 years, but it's time for new battery packs and I won't spend money on NiCd Batteries any more because the self-discharge rate is far too high, plus I needed a higher torque drill. Soo, the time came to buy a replacement. I was comparing Makita to Milwaukee, but my old Makita served me well and has seen plenty of heavy use with no failures, so I decided to go Makita.
My observation "chattering" when the unit slows down:
This is because the motors feature an electric brake which brings the unit to a slower speed or a stop much more quickly than simply freewheeling. It is intended to be a safety device, such that if you are drilling and bump yourself or someone else, you can limit injury by bringing to a stop more quickly rather than letting it freewheel until normal friction takes its course, or if you are drilling a precision hole or driving a screw into soft material, the drill will slow down more quickly than older models. The review I read on here where the user complained about the chattering didn't bother to read the specs nor the manual, otherwise he would have known it is normal operation and does not indicate a faulty motor, but an operational brake.
The pros:
BHP452 Drill
The BHP452 1/2" drill is solidly built and the transmission has a very clear detent when switching between clutched screwdriver, hammer drill, and drill modes. Contrary to what many have told me about Makita tools, construction quality seems to have improved since the early '90s; It does take two hands to shift modes but I consider this a pro, and is no different than having to use both hands to adjust the clutch on my older Makita drills.
Not counting the battery pack, the BHP452 is actually as compact as my smaller 9.6V makita drill and is about the same weight as either of my old drills. What makes this surprising is that the new drill is so much more powerful than my old 6095D drill. I found it was possible to stall the old drills by grabbing on to the chuck even in low speed/high torque mode. I cannot make the BHP452 stall even in high speed/low torque mode at half speed. This drill is rated at 450 in-lbs, or 37.5 ft-lbs of torque, which is enough for all but the largest hole-cutting jobs. I have only had a few opportunities to use it so far but it held up on a single charge for an hour of steady intermittent use, and when I put the battery on the charger, it was topped up within 5 minutes.
Sound level between the BHP452 and the 5095D is very comparable - within 2 dB on a sound meter at equivalent distance. The apparent loudness is slightly higher for the BHP452, but it's due to the higher pitch.
Electric Brake and Brush Servicing The BHP452 features an electric brake which automatically engages every time you let go of the trigger, unlike the old models. I do notice there is some internal arcing when the brake is engaged so I'm going to be checking the brushes after heavy use. It is worth noting that on the BHP452 Makita has made brush removal and replacement very easy via a service cover, whereas on the old tools you had to competely dismantle the unit to service it, and it is designed for user-servicing as evidenced by the brush replacement instructions in the manual.
LED The LED can come in handy, it's not a gimmick, but neither is it a replacement for a proper work light. Where it is most useful is for tight spaces where a work light would be unwieldy. It adds just enough light for working in tight spaces where you might otherwise have to work by feel, so it's a nice feature but by no means would I choose to or not to buy the drill for an integrated light.
Reversal switch The forward/reverse clutch is different from the 6095D - I really liked the thumb-actuated reverse switch on my older drill, but I am finding the reverse switch location on the BHP452 to be at least as convenient as the location I am used to - and indeed more similar to wired power drills, so that's a plus.
Shape: the BHP452 drill is easy to fit in surprisingly tight spaces I would never be able to use my 9.6V drills in. Somehow, it is more compact than my old 6010D thanks to the overall layout of the drill.
Cooling: the BHP452 is obviously intended for high duty cycles and high-torque needs because the internal cooling fan moves a surprisingly huge amount of air. It seems like it would require dedicated effort to overheat the motor.
Clutch The torque adjustment in driver mode is typical Makita: it is highly adjustable and helps prevent you from stripping screws, and also enables you to sink screws to a consistent depth with less effort.
BTD141
The BTD141 is my first cordless impact wrench, and I was skeptical at first but so far the BTD141 seems to live up to the claims.
Construction: Like the BHP452 construction on the unit is strong where it counts, and like the BHP452, the BTD141 is designed to be user-serviceable, with very easy access to the brushes. I have one nit pick though: the front of the impact driver features a "glow ring" (presumably so you can find it easily if working in total darkness?) and this glow ring appears to be made of a soft molded silicone rubber, and does not fit tightly to the body. It comes off far too easily. While it's not a critical component construction-wise, it does tarnish the quality of the BTD141.
Torquey! The included BTD141 impact driver seems strong; rated at 1,330 in.lbs of torque, it translates to about 40 ft-lbs of torque, easily sufficient for a wide variety of needs. The BTD141 is powerful enough to handle brake jobs, lugnuts, and other jobs where you would normally want to use a breaker bar to loosen the bolts. In other words, most work you would need to do at home on your automobile.
Torque can't be set to a specific number, so the BTD141 is no replacement for a torque wrench. However, torque is variable, based on how hard you pull the trigger. I would definitely not use the BTD141 for final tightening of any bolts or nuts on vehicles or engines (keep your torque wrench handy for that), but use it on computer server racks without hesitation. It drives bolts in very quickly and battery life seems to hold up well.
Convenience The BTD141 impact wrench is surprisingly light, very compact (fits nicely into very tight spaces), and packs a punch. Like the BHP452, the driver includes an integrated LED which does not replace your regular work light, but does allow you to work in tight spaces in a pinch where work lights would be cumbersome or impossible.
Optimum Charger
The Optimum Charger charges the batteries very quickly; its stated time is 30 minutes, but for a deep cycle seems to be closer to 20. One thing about this charger is it includes a fan to cool the 3.0Ah batteries via the cooling vent during the charging process, and communicates with the battery pack's monitoring circuit to track temperature and voltage, and varies the charging rate accordingly. After a full charge the batteries are barely warm, whereas Makita's older NiCD system results in hot battery packs after a full charge.
By implementing this cooling, the lifetime of Li-Ion based batteries will be greatly extended, so this is a great engineering choice on Makita's part.
However, the charger is quite large, given the need to accomodate cooling fans and resultant internal ductwork. The charging process is quiet though; the fans are noticeable but only slightly more so than your typical PC. The charger by default does notify you by sound when the charging process is complete, and the tone is user-configurable, or you can disable the sound altogether.
The Cons
I can't find much negative to say about the tools. Here is what I find issue with:
BHP452Z Cons
* A magnesium or titanium case would have been nice. However having had no issues with the plastic construction of my almost-20-year-old 6095D, this is a really minor nitpick.
* An on-board bracket for at least one driver or drill bit would have been nice.
The BTD141
I have more to complain about with this tool.
* I think nearly every person buying this unit would be using it with 3/8" or 1/2" sockets whether using it on vehicles, server racks, or just lag screws. The unit features a hexogonal chuck, and no hex-to-3/8" nor hex-to-1/2" adapter is included. You must buy the socket adapters separately. For the $.50 it would cost Makita, these adapters should be included with all of their impact drivers.
* the glow ring needs to either be eliminated, or become more integral to the body; it comes off far too easily. It does not affect functionality in any way, but it can affect perception of construction quality. It's almost as if the design team got lazy on the final detail and spent literally ten seconds to design this feature; in other words, it is a poorly-executed afterthought.
* A magnesium or titanium case would have been nice. However having had no issues with the plastic construction of my almost-20-year-old 6095D, this is a really minor nitpick. However the plastic case can also be considered a definite pro in some environments: as it is non-conductive it can be used around heavy-gage low voltage cabling without risk of causing shorts; useful for servicing tractors, automobiles, etc. where bare low-voltage terminals may be present in tight spaces.
-------
An update two and a half months later. . .
First off, the tools are holding up great. I have put the drill through very heavy use and in the amount of time I would have gone through /three/ batteries on my old 9.6V 6095D drill, the BHP452 is still going strong on the first battery. It's very well worth the money.
The BTD141 on the other hand? I've found that it's not up to the task of un-torquing lug nuts on my Saab - I had to resort to a breaker bar to break them loose then I used the impact driver to finish removing them. Next time I need to remove the wheels I will experiment with the BTD141 and test the torque because it really doesn't seem to provide the specified 110.4 ft. lbs. (1,330 in.lbs) of torque. It seems to deliver approximately 41 ft-lbs. :-(
Eventually I will be checking out the BTW450Z which is good for 352 ft. lbs of torque; easily enough to loosen lug nuts after the tire shop has torqued them on way over-spec (happens every time!).
-------
Update about one year later:
The set is holding up strong, including the battery packs. I have assembled playsets for friends' kids, have drilled through countless studs to run network and AV cabling, helped a friend with remodeling his home, assembled quite a few server racks, buffed out headlights and wheels, and used the impact wrench for maintenance tasks on my car and friends' cars without running into any problems with either driver. Battery life is impressive, and even at near 100% duty cycle while running a buffer wheel, the battery pack lasts longer than the charge cycle takes on the second battery. I would definitely recommend this kit to anyone who is looking for an impact and drill kit you can depend on. Again, the only qualm I have is that the impact driver torque seems to be overstated in the specifications but other than that I have no real complaints.
18 of 20 found the following review helpful:
 Good tools, bad batteries Oct 25, 2011
By Opti Mystic
"Poco Loco"
So far these have been good tools, but the batteries tend to fail early, after maybe a dozen charges. I checked around on the web and found out there is a design bug in the battery that makes them fail early. Makita knows about it and will quietly replace batteries with under 150 charges on them, regardless of warranty.
They seem to fail if left unused for a while, then put on the charger. The symptom is flashing green and red lights on the charger, with a fairly new battery. The reason is a design bug in the control board of the battery. It's always the first cell that fails, gets deep discharged, because its the only one used to supply power to the control board. So it shows a deep discharge, while the other cells are charged. If you try to charge it 3 times with a deep discharged cell, the control board bricks the battery. It will register as bad, even though there is plenty of useful life left.
So if this happens, send them to the Makita Service Center for replacement.
If Makita won't replace them, you can probably charge them and use them on a clone charger that doesn't read the control board. Clone chargers cost about $60 on the big auction site.
Until Makita fixes this, I would not advise buying these tools.
See all 74 customer reviews on Amazon.com
|
| | |
